Presenting the Winners from Our Cakes & Cookies Contest (2024)

Home Recipes Meal Types Desserts

Home cooks sent us their favorite cakes and cookies, fresh from the oven. These baked goods are more than just good, they're the best.

1/11

Grand Prize: Scotcharookies

I wanted a bakery-style cookie with the rich flavor and experience of a scotcharoo. I searched for recipes but came up empty, so I made my own, starring the classic combo of peanut butter, chocolate and Rice Krispies. —Ellen Mathewson, Bartonville, Illinois

Check out ourcontest pageto learn more about our contests and submit your own recipes for consideration.

2/11

1st Place: Cranberry Orange Layer Cake with Rosemary

This special layer cake has a refreshing orange flavor with a hint of rosemary. Since it’s an oil-based cake, it is easy to make and also has a tender crumb. Garnish with sugared cranberries and rosemary for an elevated look. —Lindsay Graham, Conestoga, Pennsylvania

3/11

2nd Place: Classic Almond Ricotta Cake

After I started making homemade ricotta cheese, I was inspired to use it in desserts, not just savory dishes. This melt-in-your-mouth cake is full of almond flavor. It is elegant enough to serve as a dessert for guests, while simple enough for a sweet snack during the week. Add ingredients like lemon zest or fresh blueberries for a change of pace. —Carrie Dault, Baxter, Tennessee

4/11

3rd Place: Butterscotch Pecan Pound Cake

My father just loves nuts and anything butterscotch flavored, so I’m always on the lookout for recipes that combine these two favorites of his (and mine as well). I altered a cream cheese pound cake recipe to come up with this butterscotch pecan version, and I think it’s even tastier than the original. For more intense brown sugar fIavor, use dark instead of light brown sugar. I’ve also substituted walnuts for pecans with great results. —Lisa Varner, El Paso, Texas

5/11

Most Innovative: Red Velvet Cheesecake Cookies

Cream cheese and red velvet cake go together like bread and butter, so I figured why not make a cheesecake-filled red velvet cookie? The key ingredient here is farmer cheese: a denser, drier cheese similar in texture to feta. It keeps the filling from being too soft and gives the sweet cookie a little bit of tang. —Kristyne Mcdougle Walter, Lorain, Ohio

6/11

Runner-Up: Almond Joy Cupcakes

I created these Almond Joy cupcakes for my daughter, Julianna, after our spring break trip to Fort Lauderdale. I wanted to thank her for the “joy” she brought me during our time together. She’s a huge help to me in the kitchen and a big inspiration in my life. —Jennifer Gilbert, Brighton, Michigan

7/11

Runner-Up: Caramel Apple Toffee Cookies

I had bags of caramel bits and toffee bits in my pantry that I needed to use, and that’s how these cookies were born. The combination of chewy caramel and fresh apple is amazing. —Pamela Shank, Parkersburg, West Virginia

8/11

Runner-Up: Cherry Cordial Cookies

This is hands-down my most-requested cookie recipe at holiday gatherings. These cookies are reminiscent of chocolate-covered cherries, so they are a decadent treat. —Noelle Myers, Grand Forks, North Dakota

9/11

Runner-Up: Chocolate-Covered-Strawberry Shortbread

I wanted to create a cookie that embraced chocolate-covered strawberries, so I started riffing on shortbread. It took a few tries, but I nailed it with this version! Freeze-dried strawberries lend big berry flavor without making the cookies soggy. Be sure to use good-quality chocolate, too. —Jennifer Nystrom, Pooler, Georgia

10/11

Runner-Up: Copycat Samoa Cookies

We love Girl Scout cookies, especially Samoas, but you can only buy those once a year. I started tweaking a tried-and-true no-bake cookie recipe and wound up with this Samoa taste-alike. It’s a great recipe to make with kids! —Donna Gribbins, Shelbyville, Kentucky

11/11

Runner-Up: Key Lime Pie Cookies

I love baking cookies for family and friends. I was getting bored making the same cookies over and over again, so I decided to come up with my own. My love of Key lime pie inspired these. —Suzy Wade, Deltona, Florida

Alyssa has been with Taste of Home for just over a year, but has been in food and lifestyle publishing since 2018. As an associate editor, she writes and edits recipe collections and runs several newsletters, including Top 10, Slow Cooker & Casseroles, Quick Dinners and Balanced Plate.When she's not planning her next trip overseas, you can find Alyssa trying out new Chicago restaurants or watching a movie.